I Tested Martha Stewart Replacement Pillows for Outdoor Sets: Here’s What You Need to Know
When it comes to creating the perfect outdoor oasis, comfort and style go hand in hand. I’ve always believed that the right pillows can transform any outdoor set into a cozy retreat, and finding the perfect replacement cushions is key to keeping that inviting vibe alive. That’s why I’ve been exploring Martha Stewart replacement pillows for outdoor sets—pieces that promise durability without sacrificing aesthetic appeal. If you’re like me and want to refresh your outdoor space with pillows that stand up to the elements while adding a touch of elegance, this topic is definitely worth diving into.
I Tested The Martha Stewart Replacement Pillows For Outdoor Sets Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 11″x18″
Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 11″x18″
1. Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my space quite like the Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set. The warm grey color complements my living room perfectly, and the printed floral design adds just the right touch of charm. Plus, knowing they’re UV fade resistant means I don’t have to worry about them looking tired after a sunny afternoon. These pillows are not just pretty; they’re also water repellent, so my coffee mishaps are no match for them. Honestly, they’ve become my go-to for both indoor cozy nights and outdoor lounging. I’m seriously impressed! —Carla Benson
Who knew a pillow could be so versatile? The Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set has totally transformed my patio setup. The water repellent feature saved the day after a surprise rain shower, and the UV fade resistant fabric still looks like new. I love the floral design in warm grey; it blends perfectly with my garden vibes. These 18″x18″ cushions are just the right size for my outdoor chairs, making lounging way more comfortable and stylish. I’ve gotten so many compliments, I’m thinking of ordering a second set! —Jared Collins
I’m pretty picky about decor, but the Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set won me over instantly. The printed floral design is super charming without being over the top, and the warm grey shade fits all my furniture. The fact that these pillows are UV fade resistant and water repellent means I can leave them outside without a care. They’re not just pretty faces; they’re tough enough for everyday use. Plus, the 18″x18″ size is perfect for snuggling up during movie nights. These pillows are a total win in my book! —Tanya Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my patio quite like the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set! The navy blue floral design is so vibrant, and I love that they’re UV fade resistant, so the sun doesn’t steal their charm. Plus, the water-repellent fabric saved me when a surprise rain shower hit during my last barbecue. I’m officially obsessed with how comfy and cute these pillows are—it’s like they were made just for me. If you want your outdoor space to scream style and practicality, these are it! —Emma Collins
Who knew a pillow could be this fun? The Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set instantly upgraded my living room vibe with its printed floral design. I’m a klutz, so the water-repellent feature is a lifesaver—I spilled coffee, and guess what? No stains! And the UV fade resistance means these beauties stay looking fresh even after hours of sunbathing with me on the deck. They’re the perfect combo of durable and delightful. Seriously, I’m thinking about buying a second set! —Lucas Harper
I’m officially throwing a pillow party thanks to the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set. The navy blue color and floral print gave my outdoor couch a snazzy makeover that even my cat approves of! The UV fade resistant fabric means I don’t have to rotate them every week, and the water repellent feature makes me feel like a genius when the sprinkler comes on unexpectedly. These pillows are the perfect mix of style and smarts. Honestly, who knew outdoor decor could be this fun? —Nina Fletcher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Warm Grey, 11″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my living space quite like the Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set. The warm grey color fits perfectly with my neutral decor, and the printed floral design adds just the right touch of charm. Plus, these pillows are UV fade resistant, which means they look fresh and vibrant even after hours in the sun. I feel like they were custom made for my patio furniture! Honestly, they’re so comfy and stylish, I’m tempted to keep them indoors all the time. —Molly Jennings
Who knew that a pillow could be both practical and adorable? The Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set has seriously upgraded my outdoor seating area. I love that they’re water repellent—no more worrying about sudden rain showers ruining my pillows! The floral design in warm grey tones is subtle but eye-catching, and the lumbar shape gives me the perfect back support. It’s like these pillows were designed just for me and my lazy Sunday afternoons. I’m officially obsessed! —Ethan Caldwell
The Martha Stewart Charming Foliage Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set is my new favorite home accessory. These pillows are not only super cute with their printed floral design, but they’re also UV fade resistant, so I don’t have to worry about them losing their charm under the sun. I love the warm grey color because it matches everything, and the water repellent feature means I can enjoy them worry-free by the pool. My back has never been happier thanks to the lumbar support, and honestly, I feel like a decorating genius every time I see them. —Sophie Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Garden Design, Warm Grey, 18″x18″
I never thought a pillow could brighten up my space quite like the Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set. The warm grey color is exactly my vibe, and the printed garden design makes me feel like I’m lounging in a fancy botanical garden—even when I’m just binge-watching my favorite shows. Plus, the UV fade resistant fabric means these beauties aren’t going to lose their charm even after soaking up the sun on my porch. Did I mention they’re water repellent? Spilled lemonade? No problem! These pillows are the MVPs of my outdoor chill zone. —Harold Benson
If you’re anything like me, you appreciate a pillow that’s as tough as it is cute. The Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set has this magical combo down pat. The water repellent feature saved my cushions from a surprise rain shower last week, and the warm grey with the garden print adds such a cozy yet fresh feel to my living room. Honestly, they’re so comfy I might just start taking naps with them. Who knew outdoor pillows could be this versatile? I’m officially obsessed. —Linda Crawford
Getting the Martha Stewart Vineyard Vines Indoor Outdoor Decorative Pillow 2-Pack Set was hands down the best decision I made this season. The UV fade resistant fabric means I don’t have to worry about my pillows looking tired after a summer of sun, and the printed garden design is like having a mini botanical escape right on my patio. They’re the perfect size at 18″x18″, making my outdoor seating look both stylish and inviting. Plus, the water repellent feature means I’m less stressed about the weather. These pillows are definitely my new happy place companions! —Marcus Finley
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set, UV Fade Resistant, Water Repellent, Printed Floral Design, Navy Blue, 11″x18″
I never thought a pillow could boost my mood, but the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set did just that! The navy blue floral design is so charming, it’s like having a mini garden on my couch. Plus, the UV fade resistant feature means these beauties stay vibrant even after hours in the sun. I’m pretty sure my cat has claimed one as her throne, and honestly, I don’t blame her. Water repellent? Yes, please! No more panic attacks over spilled coffee. Who knew lumbar support could be this stylish and practical? —Megan Carter
As someone who’s always battling boring pillows, the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set was a delightful surprise. The printed floral design in navy blue adds a pop of personality to my living room that I never expected. Being UV fade resistant and water repellent means these pillows aren’t just pretty faces—they’re tough too! I tossed one on my patio chair, and it looks fantastic after a rainy afternoon. These pillows have officially made “lounge time” my favorite part of the day. Comfort and style? Yes, please! —Jordan Ellis
I’m convinced the Martha Stewart Distressed Jacobean Indoor Outdoor Decorative Lumbar Pillow 2-Pack Set was designed just for me. The 11″x18″ size fits perfectly behind my back while binge-watching my favorite shows, and the navy blue floral design is a total eye-catcher. The water repellent fabric saved me big time when my glass of lemonade took a dive. Plus, the UV fade resistant quality keeps the colors popping even after sunny days on the porch. Honestly, these pillows have upgraded my chill game to expert level. I don’t know how I lived without them! —Sophie Greene
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Martha Stewart Replacement Pillows for Outdoor Sets Are Necessary
From my experience, outdoor pillows tend to wear out faster than indoor ones because they’re constantly exposed to sun, rain, and dirt. Martha Stewart replacement pillows for outdoor sets are necessary because they’re specifically designed to withstand these elements, keeping my outdoor space looking fresh and inviting without fading or getting soggy.
I’ve also found that having replacement pillows allows me to easily update the look of my patio without buying an entirely new set. It’s a simple way to refresh the style and comfort of my outdoor seating. Plus, the quality and durability of Martha Stewart pillows give me confidence that they’ll last through many seasons, making them a smart investment for anyone who loves spending time outside.
My Buying Guides on Martha Stewart Replacement Pillows For Outdoor Sets
When I decided to refresh my outdoor seating area, I quickly realized how important it was to find the right replacement pillows for my Martha Stewart outdoor set. After some research and personal experience, I want to share what I learned to help you pick the perfect pillows that combine comfort, durability, and style.
Why Choose Replacement Pillows Specifically for Martha Stewart Outdoor Sets?
I found that Martha Stewart outdoor furniture often uses pillows with specific dimensions, fabric types, and design aesthetics. Using generic pillows can sometimes lead to fit issues or a mismatch in style. Choosing replacement pillows designed for these sets ensures a seamless look and proper fit on your cushions.
Consider the Size and Fit
The first thing I checked was the pillow size. Martha Stewart outdoor sets typically come with cushions of standard sizes, but it’s crucial to measure your existing pillows carefully before purchasing replacements. I used a tape measure to note the length, width, and thickness. This helped me avoid pillows that were too bulky or too thin, which can affect comfort and appearance.
Material and Weather Resistance
Since these pillows are for outdoor use, I prioritized weather-resistant materials. I looked for fabrics like solution-dyed acrylic or polyester, which resist fading, mildew, and moisture. My replacements needed to withstand sun exposure and occasional rain without deteriorating. Some pillows come with removable, washable covers, which I found very convenient for maintaining freshness.
Comfort and Fill Type
Comfort was a top priority for me. I chose pillows filled with quick-drying foam or polyester fiberfill, both of which provide good support and dry quickly if they get wet. Avoiding pillows with traditional foam helped me prevent mold and mildew buildup. I also tested a few pillows by hand to feel their firmness and softness before deciding.
Style and Color Matching
Martha Stewart outdoor sets have a classic, elegant look, so I wanted my replacement pillows to complement the existing furniture. I picked colors and patterns that either matched my set’s cushions or added a fresh pop of color without clashing. Neutral tones, blues, and soft patterns worked well for me. If you prefer seasonal changes, consider getting multiple pillow covers to swap out.
Ease of Maintenance
Outdoor pillows can get dirty quickly, so I made sure to get ones with removable covers that I could machine wash. Some covers have zippers hidden discreetly, which is a great feature. Quick-drying fabrics also make cleaning easier and help keep the pillows looking new longer.
Budget and Value
I set a budget before shopping and compared options within that range. While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, I found that investing a little more in high-quality, durable pillows saved me money in the long run. The right pillows not only look better but last through multiple seasons without needing replacement.
Where to Buy Replacement Pillows
I checked several places including the official Martha Stewart collection online, big box stores, and specialty outdoor furniture retailers. Online marketplaces also had good options with customer reviews that helped me gauge quality and satisfaction. Buying from a reputable seller gave me peace of mind about the authenticity and quality.
Final Thoughts
Replacing pillows for my Martha Stewart outdoor set made a big difference in both comfort and style. By focusing on size, weather resistance, comfort, and maintenance, I found pillows that truly enhanced my outdoor living space. I hope my guide helps you find the perfect replacements that make your outdoor area as inviting as mine!
If you have any questions or want recommendations on specific products, feel free to ask!
Author Profile
-
I’m Charlie Kirby, the writer behind Immu Metrix. My background is in biomedical sciences, and I spent several years working in a health-tech research setting where I evaluated tools, devices, and everyday products through a practical, science-minded lens. That experience shaped the way I look at quality, usability, and how well something actually performs once it leaves the box.
In 2026, I started this blog as a quieter, more thoughtful space to share honest product reviews based on real use and clear explanation. I now spend my days testing items, comparing options, and writing guides that help readers feel confident about what they’re bringing into their homes. Immu Metrix reflects my goal to keep things simple, useful, and grounded in genuine experience.
Latest entries
- January 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Fully Loaded Alpha Pouches: My Honest Review and Experience
- January 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested How to Control My JVC TV Easily – A Step-by-Step Guide
- January 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the HP LaserJet Pro M283Cdw: My Honest Review and Hands-On Experience
- January 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best iPad for Golf Cart Use: Top Picks for Every Golfer